User login

Navigation

You are here

Thank You Reviewers

Nuwan Dewapriya's picture

I have noticed several online postings criticizing reviewers but haven’t seen a post appreciating them. Talking more about bad reviewers can give a wrong impression to the young researchers that the majority of the reviewers are bad. Therefore, I thought of sharing my experience.

We have published over 20 papers, and of course, got several rejections. However, I haven’t encountered an unreasonable reviewer yet. A reviewer can occasionally miss a point in a manuscript, but the reviewers repeatedly asked us fair questions and provided meaningful comments.

For example, I have attached one of our recent responses to a reviewer. It can be clearly seen that the reviewer’s comments helped us to significantly improve the quality of the manuscript. That was not an isolated incident. In 3 out of our 5 latest publications, we included a statement like “The insightful comments of the reviewer are gratefully acknowledged” because we believe that the reviewers helped us to improve our manuscripts significantly.

Thank you, reviewers.

AttachmentSize
PDF icon Response to the Reviewer_CMS_2021.pdf414.13 KB
Subscribe to Comments for "Thank You Reviewers "

Recent comments

More comments

Syndicate

Subscribe to Syndicate